Everything you need to know about Madden 23 Ultimate Team is right here, including the release date, TOTY nominees, and our prediction.
Madden 23 TOTY release date & player nominees
To vote for the players you believe should make the final cut, go to Madden 23 TOTY voting page. Remember that each person can only submit one set of TOTY votes per category, so choose wisely.
TOTY voting will take place from February 17 to February 22. After the voting period ends, Madden 23 Ultimate Team will count the votes and announce the TOTY on March 8, the day before it goes live in the game on March 9.
There are 98 TOTY nominees in Madden 23 Ultimate Team, which are as follows:
Cornerbacks
- Charvarius Ward – 49ers
- Darius Slay Jr. – Eagles
- Jaire Alexander – Packers
- Jalen Ramsey – Rams
- Marlon Humphrey – Ravens
- Patrick Surtain II – Broncos
- Sauce Gardner – Jets
- Stephon Gilmore – Colts
- Tyson Campbell – Jaguars
Defensive Line
- Brian Burns (LE) – Panthers
- Chris Jones (DT) – Chiefs
- Derrick Brown (DT) – Panthers
- Dexter Lawrence (DT) – Giants
- Jerry Hughes (LE) – Texans
- Maxx Crosby (LE) – Raiders
- Montez Sweat (RE) – Commanders
- Myles Garrett (RE) – Browns
- Nick Bosa (RE) – 49ers
- Quinnen Williams (DT) – Jets
Half Backs
- Christian McCaffrey – 49ers
- Jamal Williams – Lions
- Josh Jacobs – Raiders
- Nick Chubb – Browns
- Saquon Barkley – Giants
- Tony Pollard – Cowboys
Middle Linebackers
- Bobby Wagner – Rams
- Demario Davis – Saints
- Fred Warner – 49ers
- Lavonte David – Buccaneers
- Tremaine Edmunds – Bills
Offensive Line
- Andrew Thomas (LT) – Giants
- Creed Humphrey (C) – Chiefs
- Chris Lindstrom (RG) – Falcons
- Christian Darrisaw (LT) – Vikings
- Frank Ragnow (C) – Lions
- Jason Kelce (C) – Eagles
- Joe Thuney (LG) – Chiefs
- Joel Bitonio (LG) – Browns
- Lane Johnson (RT) – Eagles
- Michael Onwenu (RG) – Patriots
- Quentin Nelson (LG) – Colts
- Ryan Ramczyk (RT) – Saints
- Trent Williams (LT) – 49ers
- Tristen Wirfs (RT) – Buccaneers
- Zack Martin (RG) – Cowboys
Outside Linebackers
- Alex Highsmith (LOLB) – Steeles
- Danielle Hunter (LOLB) – Vikings
- Dre Greenlaw (ROLB) – 49ers
- Haason Reddick (LOLB) – Eagles
- Jaelan Phillips (ROLB) – Dolphins
- Khalil Mack (ROLB) – Chargers
- Matthew Judon (LOLB) – Patriots
- Micah Parsons (ROLB) – Cowboys
Quarterbacks
- Jalen Hurts – Eagles
- Joe Burrow – Bengals
- Josh Allen – Bills
- Justin Fields – Bears
- Justin Herbert – Chargers
- Patrick Mahomes – Chiefs
Safeties
- Antoine Winfield (FS) – Buccaneers
- Budda Baker (SS) – Cardinals
- Derwin James (SS) – Chargers
- Justin Simmons (FS) – Broncos
- Kevin Byard (FS) – Titans
- Minkah Fitzpatrick (FS) – Steelers
- Rodney McCloud (SS) – Colts
- Ryan Neal (SS) – Seahawks
- Talanoa Hufanga (SS) – 49ers
- Tyrann Mathieu (FS) – Saints
Specialists
- Aaron Jones (3HB) – Packers
- Austin Ekeler (3HB) – Chargers
- Alec Ingold (FB) – Dolphins
- Braden Mann (P) – Jets
- Cameron Heyward (RDE) – Steelers
- Christian Wilkins (RDE) – Dolphins
- Daniel Carlson (K) – Raiders
- Jamal Agnew (KR) – Jaguars
- Javon Hargrave (RDE) – Eagles
- Jerick McKinnon (3HB) – Chiefs
- Justin Tucker (K) – Ravens
- Keisean Nixon (KR) – Packers
- Kyle Juszczyk (FB) – 49ers
- Nyheim Hines (KR) – Bills
- Patrick Ricard (FB) – Ravens
- Tommy Townsend (P) – Chiefs
Tight Ends
- George Kittle – 49ers
- Mark Andrews – Ravens
- T.J. Hockenson – Vikings
- Travis Kelce – Chiefs
Wide Receivers
- A.J. Brown – Eagles
- Amon Ra-St. Brown – Lions
- CeeDee Lamb – Cowboys
- Davante Adams – Raiders
- Jamar Chase – Bengals
- Jaylen Waddle – Dolphins
- Justin Jefferson – Vikings
- Stefon Diggs – Bills
- Tyreek Hill – Dolphins
Madden 23 TOTY prediction
So, out of a total of 98 nominees, who will make the Madden 23 TOTY? Here’s our prediction based on how well these players performed during the regular season and playoffs (if any) in 2022, as well as how dominant they were throughout the season and prior to it.
Defense
- Derwin James (SS) – Chargers
- Dexter Lawrence (DT) – Giants
- Fred Warner (MLB) – 49ers
- Haason Reddick (LOLB) – Eagles
- Jalen Ramsey (CB) – Rams
- Justin Simmons (FS) – Broncos
- Maxx Crosby (LE) – Raiders
- Micah Parson (ROLB) – Cowboys
- Nick Bosa (RE) – 49ers
- Sauce Gardner (CB) – Jets
Offense
- Davante Adams (WR) – Raiders
- Jason Kelce (C) – Eagles
- Joe Burrow (QB) – Bengals
- Joe Thuney (LG) – Chiefs
- Josh Jacobs (HB) – Raiders
- Justin Jefferson (WR) – Vikings
- Lane Johnson (RT) – Eagles
- Travis Kelce (TE) – Chiefs
- Trent Williams (LT) – 49ers
- Zack Martin (RG) – Cowboys
Specialists
- Austin Ekeler (3HB) – Chargers
- Daniel Carlson (K) – Raiders
- Jamar Chase (SLWR) – Bengals
- Javon Hargrave (RDE) – Eagles
- Kyle Juszczyk (FB) – 49ers
- Nyheim Hines (KR) – Bills
- Stephon Gilmore (SLCB) – Colts
- Tommy Townsend (P) – Chiefs
As you may have noticed, we exclude some players from this prediction because they already have top-tier cards, most notably Mahomes.
That being said, stay tuned to see which nominees are chosen, and in the meantime, vote if you haven’t already.
